The most essential skill you need to develop in order to get great results from your wood-burning or charcoal smoker is maintaining the correct temperature throughout the cooking process. When temperatures drop or spike, you run the risk of ruining the flavor and texture of your meat.
One of the reasons that pellet smoker temperature control system designs are popular is because they allow you to essentially set it and forget it. But pellet smokers don't always give you the best flavor and you'll often have to make compromises when selecting the types of pellets you can use.
Charcoal and wood smokers offer more flexibility since you have control over the type of fuel you use, but you'll have to put in more time and work to keep the temperature fluctuations at a minimum. There are a number of factors that go into getting the perfect temperature and level of smoke from a wood or charcoal smoker.
How Do I Control the Heat in My Smoker?
In order for your smoker to work the way you want, you have to control three elements. These are airflow, fire temperature, and smoke consistency. While these three aspects are interrelated, they are also independently controlled.
Depending on the type of smoker, you'll need to adjust certain aspects of your cooking process to get the results you are looking for.
Before we go any deeper into this process, it should be pointed out that your smoker should be clean, particularly if you've had some trouble in the past. Spend a little time to get accumulated soot and grease removed and your food will taste better and your smoker will work better. It is also vital that your firebox is clean and free of ash before you start smoking.
Setting and Maintaining the Fire Box
The most difficult aspect of using a wood or charcoal smoker is maintaining the fire. It all starts with setting your fire correctly in the first place.
One tool that we highly recommend you pick up is a charcoal chimney starter. This is a simple tool that lets you easily start charcoal and move it into the firebox when you are ready.
Starting the Fire
Start by loading about one chimney worth of lump charcoal into the firebox unlit. Then, start another chimney of charcoal burning. Let the charcoal burn until the top-most visible parts are beginning to ash over and the smoke is clear or lightly colored.
Add the burning coals to the firebox on top of the unlit coals. This will form the base of your coal bed which is your main heat source. Let this burn for 10 to 15 minutes before putting your meat in the smoker.
This is when you'll start to make your initial vent adjustment.
Using the Vents to Control Temperature on Charcoal and Wood Burning Grills and Smokers
The primary thing that you'll need to get familiar with is how to set the air vents on your smoker to get the temperature you want. Different smokers are going to react slightly different to changes in airflow, but there are some basics that apply to all types, whether you are using an offset smoker, a kettle smoker, or a drum smoker.
Adjusting the Intake and Exhaust Vent
Most smokers will work best if you start out with the top vent at least halfway open. Start with the intake vent, which is the bottom vent, about one-quarter open. Monitor the temperature rises as the charcoal begins to burn.
You don't want the heat to shoot up, but you also don't want it to take too long to come to temperature.
More Oxygen Equals More Heat
Once the temperature is slightly above the temp you want, close the bottom vent until the smoker's temperature begins to drop, then open it slightly to stabilize the temp.
At this point, you should keep an eye on the coals to make sure they don't begin to die out. If they do begin to die, open the intake slightly to pull oxygen into the firebox.
You'll want the exhaust vent open more to allow hot air to exit.
It is a good idea to have a chimney of charcoal lit and ready before the firebox starts to lose temperature inside so you can maintain your target temp. Adding fuel isn't always necessary on shorter smokes, but if you are doing a beef brisket, you'll need to add fuel periodically.
Using the Exhaust Damper to Get the Right Temperature
The best way to maintain temperatures is by using the top vent rather than the intake vent. What you are looking for is a consistent, even fire in the firebox, and you should be able to get that condition by adjusting the vent at the beginning and largely leaving it alone.
Watching the smoke from your exhaust vent and monitoring whether the coals are burning properly will tell you that you've got the intake dampers adjusted correctly.
Understanding the Color of the Smoke
One of the key mistakes people make is thinking that more smoke means more flavor. In fact, too much smoke can overpower the natural flavor of your meat and can leave you with a bitter, acidic flavor.
White smoke is generally undesirable. What you are looking to achieve is thin, bluish smoke.
One of the many reasons we don't recommend using charcoal briquets is because they often introduce hot gases that can give meat weird flavors. Instead, stick with natural lump charcoal for heat and use wood chunks or wood chips to add flavor.
Using Wood Chips and Chunks
Once you've got a good bed of coals burning, you can use wood chips or chunks to add distinct flavors and aromas. There are a couple of ways to use wood properly to get the desired goals.
One method is to start the wood chunks outside of the firebox and let them burn off for a few minutes to allow the initial white smoke to dissipate, then add them to the firebox.
On an offset smoker, you may have a grate that sits above the coals. This is an excellent option for adding wood because it will allow you to position the chunks so they smolder rather than burn. Burning wood will cause the temperature to spike.
The trick is to get the chunks to burn just enough to add a thin smoke without creating plumes of dense, white smoke.
Tips on How to Achieve the Perfect Temperature
You can use a few tricks to help maintain an even temperature.
One of the key ways to do this is to use a water pan. On an offset smoker, the water pan is typically placed below the grates to create an indirect heat source.
Kettle and drum smokers benefit from a water pan because the pan deflects the heat. Water will also hold heat, helping to give you an even air temperature.
One key element that is often overlooked is that the construction of a smoker itself can impact the ability to maintain temperature.
Many of the low-cost smokers out there use thin metal doors that don't seal well, which lets the hot gases rising escape too quickly and makes it difficult to regulate temperature.
Customizing for Better Results
Sometimes, all it takes is adding some fireproof seals around doors and adding food-grade caulking to seams that leak. In cold weather, an old welding blanket wrapped around the smoker will help keep temperatures stable.
Notes on Thermometers
Most smokers have built-in thermometers that let you monitor their internal temperature. The problem is that many of these thermometers aren't correctly calibrated, so you don't know the actual temp in the smoker.
If your smoker has a non-adjustable thermometer, it's a good idea to replace it with one that can be calibrated. Using a dedicated thermometer air probe to check the temps on each side of the grill temperature can also help.
It takes some practice to find the balance to adjust smoker temperature with the exhaust damper open and the intake damper to hit the ideal temperature. You'll also need to discover how much charcoal is enough charcoal to slow smoke without overloading the fire.
Depending on whether you are aiming for a steady temperature of 225ºF or more, you may need to adjust how much lit coals you use and what types of wood you add to prevent getting thick white smoke.
Often, wood will smoke when the fire isn't hot enough, so it is important to practice hitting the target temperature and balancing the grill's temperature to make the best smoked meats.
Finally, there are some other factors that come into play. The air temp where your smoker is can play havoc with keeping the temperature correct for the meat smoking process.
When it's cold out, it is harder to get high temps, and likewise, hot weather makes low temperatures difficult to maintain. You'll need to get used to making various adjustments to keep your charcoal grill at the desired temperature over the course of the smoking process.
Finally, the type and size of charcoal and wood you use will cause changes to the temperature. Some woods like mesquite and many kinds of nut woods tend to burn hotter than hardwoods like oak.
Hickory can quickly overpower delicate meats, while some woods like apple may not impart enough flavor to be worth it.
The size of the lump charcoal pieces also impacts the temperature and the time that you'll get out of your coals. Small pieces of charcoal burn quickly and will make balancing the temperature more challenging.
The good news is that with a little trial and error, you'll find the perfect combination of vent settings, coal amounts, and wood types to get the perfect results you are after.
The Bearded Butchers are dedicated to providing as much information as we possibly can to help you understand how to best process and prepare meats of all kinds. To help you, we maintain a blog and Youtube channel with lots of free, high-quality information. The Bearded Butchers and Beardedbutchers.com are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. This means that The Bearded Butchers may receive a commission if you click on a link above and make a purchase on Amazon.com.